When you ask people what souvenirs you can get during your trip to New York, many of them will come up with something predictable: keychains, mugs with the Statue of Liberty, or cheap t-shirts emblazoned with “I ❤️ NY.”
These mass-produced trinkets do serve as physical proof of a visit, but do they really mean anything to you? Nowadays, we are entering an era of curated experiences, minimalist living, and Instagram storytelling, so the boring souvenir has become unacceptable. Here are some ideas for the best souvenirs you can buy in NYC.
Photo by Ferdinand Stöhr on Unsplash
But before we start perusing all the particular souvenirs that you can find in NYC, let’s get you connected and ready to search online for all the info that you need. This trip can be the best opportunity to try Yoho Mobile’s free eSIM! See how easy it is to install, and if you like the service and want to stay with us, use the promo code YOHO12 for 12% off.
What Do You Want from a Souvenir?
Just ask yourself, does this item mean anything to me, or the person I plan to gift it to? Does it resonate with personal stories and cultural depth? And picture a white t-shirt with “I ❤️ NY” on it. You will probably use it once or twice before it ends up in a donation bin. So let’s find souvenir ideas that stir memory and emotion. Authenticity means it will stay with you for many happy years.
And New York City is uniquely positioned to answer that call. With its five boroughs bursting with history, subcultures, and creativity, it offers a thousand different ways to take home something special. Here, a keepsake isn’t just a physical object. It can be a fragment of Brooklyn’s past, the scent of a Harlem jazz club, the taste of Queens’ street food, or the hum of a subway musician on a summer night.
Best Souvenirs Made from the Literal Materials of the City
New York City is a city that never ceases to evolve, and if you visit more than once, you’ll notice how buildings are torn down, streets are repaved, and warehouses are reborn as cafes and studios.
Even the discarded materials follow the spirit of the city, and oftentimes find new life as keepsakes. So let’s check out which are the most famous from every borough.
Brooklyn
-
Brownstone Bricks: These bricks are salvaged from historic row houses and are a physical reminder that carries the texture of a century-old neighborhood. And no, you don’t have to get a whole brick; you can get a small piece.
-
Handcrafted Wooden Coasters: These are made from reclaimed wood, often sourced from DUMBO or Red Hook warehouses. A nice blend of rustic charm with authentic urban grit.
-
Street Art Prints: Some artists use recycled NYC newspapers as the canvas for their prints, capturing a piece of both artistic and journalistic history.
Photo by Miltiadis Fragkidis on Unsplash
Manhattan
-
Subway Map Glassware: Artisans take old pieces of glass and print them with the MTA map, so you can get quite a unique piece of home decor.
-
Concrete Jewelry: Only in Manhattan can you add such a piece to your collection. And it’s pretty magical how ground-down concrete from building demolitions becomes wearable history.
-
Fire Escape Sculptures: Artists salvage fire escape pieces and shape them into wall art or mini structures.
Photo by Luca Bravo on Unsplash
Queens
-
Factory Woodcrafts: Artisans transform aged wood from defunct factories into bowls, utensils, and ornaments. It’s a perfect gift if you have eco-conscious or minimalist friends.
-
Borough Map Art: You can get a Queens-focused print on recycled paper that showcases local pride and geography. And, if you want to add a personal touch, you can put pins on the places you visited.
-
Cemetery Stones: Don’t go to any local cemeteries to vandalize the tombstones. Make sure you get them from ethical sources. But these polished stones from 19th-century cemeteries can be interesting souvenirs.
Photo by Jimmy Woo on Unsplash
Best Souvenirs You Can Eat (But Shouldn’t Forget)
Eating is always a great activity during any kind of travel, but in NYC, the experience is on another level. So, if you want to share this full-sensory experience, here are some edible souvenirs that you can easily add to your luggage.
-
Black and White Cookies: They are soft, cake-like, and the split between chocolate and vanilla icing brings the best of two worlds. Zabar’s and Moishe’s offer great versions, and your family is going to love them.
-
Bagels from Ess-a-Bagel or Russ & Daughters: Bagels are a staple in NYC, and authentic New York bagels are dense, chewy, and craveable. For the best results, freeze them immediately and reheat in a toaster oven.
-
Junior’s Cheesecake Mix: Another great pick, but instead of making a disaster in your luggage, take home a boxed mix to recreate this Brooklyn classic at home.
Packing Tips for Your Edible Souvenirs:
-
Always pack perishables in airtight containers or vacuum-sealed bags.
-
Research your country’s customs rules; some international travelers may need to leave food behind at the border, while others can only pass store-bought, sealed items.
Souvenirs That Live in Your Ears and Eyes
This category will be especially helpful if you don’t have that much space in your luggage, and it’s perfectly in tone with New York’s creative energy.
Sound-Based Keepsakes:
-
Vinyl from NYC Record Shops: If you have a record player, this is a great source. Stores like Academy Records in Manhattan and Rough Trade in Brooklyn offer rare records, local artists, and deep cuts from the city’s rich musical past.
-
Podcast Episodes: Download NYC-based podcasts like The Bowery Boys (history), NYC Local Legends (interviews), or Sidewalk Confidential(subway stories) to revisit the city anytime. Plus, these are great to prepare before your trip!
Photo by Travis Yewell on Unsplash
Visual Keepsakes
-
Street Photography Prints: If you’re an artist, you can take your own photos and make them prints to decorate your house. If not, you can always get them from local artists.
-
Tattoo Shop Flash Art: Some people collect photos, and some people collect tattoos, and there are shops in NYC that sell limited edition flash sheets from in-house artists.
-
Performance Tickets: This is especially important if you have a journal. Keep your ticket stub from a Broadway show, a poetry reading, or a Central Park concert, and you’ll see how much they remind you of your trip.
Forgotten Finds: NYC’s Cultural Underbelly
We’ve been going for less conventional souvenirs to get in NYC, but there’s so much more. And now let’s explore its subcultures, activist histories, and underground creativity, and focus on finds that capture the city’s rebellious spirit.
-
Zines and Artist Books: Independent bookstores like Bluestockings and Printed Matter offer zines on everything from LGBTQ+ issues to food justice to punk rock.
-
Chapbooks of Poetry: The city’s literary scenes, especially in the East Village, produce small-run poetry chapbooks. They make meaningful gifts or keepsakes, just don’t forget to add a dedication.
-
Counter-Culture Tees: You can always add a few tees to your closet, and graphic tees printed by activist groups or radical collectives reflect local voices and causes you can support.
The Anti-Souvenir, Leave Something Behind Instead
Sometimes the best souvenir isn’t something you take, but instead, something you give. And as tourism becomes more conscious, many travelers seek ways to leave a positive footprint.
-
Seed Bombs: If you want to make locals happy after your visit, you can scatter biodegradable seed packets in neglected green spaces or community gardens.
-
Street Art Projects: NYC is pretty well known for its creativity, and you can join public art initiatives in neighborhoods like Bushwick or Williamsburg. Some allow travelers to add to temporary murals or chalk installations.
-
Little Free Libraries: If you’re traveling with a book, and you’ve just finished it, and you want to share it, you can tuck it with a note for a stranger inside one of NYC’s many free book boxes.
FAQs About the Best NY Souvenirs
Can I bring home NYC pizza?
Yes! Freeze slices as soon as possible and use airtight containers or vacuum-sealed bags to preserve freshness. For the best taste, ditch the microwave and use the oven to reheat it.
What is the best time to shop at street vendors?
The best time to shop at the many street vendors in NYC is during the weekends, especially between 11 AM and 4 PM. During those hours, vendors are active, crowds are lively, and inventory is fresh. As for the worst time, you should avoid Mondays and early mornings.
Is it okay to haggle?
Yes, but only at flea markets or craft fairs. And remember, always be polite, friendly, and respectful. Smile, make a fair offer, and don’t put pressure on the vendors.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re carrying home a chunk of cobblestone, a hand-thrown ceramic bowl, or simply a memory, NYC offers souvenirs that tell a story. They reflect the textures, sounds, flavors, and voices of the city. They’re personal, layered, and overall, they’re real.
New York doesn’t want you to just visit; it wants you to connect, so let your souvenirs reflect that.